There is a longer version of this thought-provoking post, also including Carmack's thoughts in 02012, at https://cbarrete.com/carmack.html. But maybe that version has not also had threads about it.
I do think it's a better page, but I wouldn't change the link if I were in charge. On the other hand, I think everyone is grateful that you're in charge of HN and not me. Especially not me. So I think you should use your judgment.
