Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

The days of GNU significant relevance have passed haven’t they? There’s so many incarnations of Linux that surely GNU is relevant in only a small number of cases?


> The days of GNU significant relevance have passed haven’t they?

why on earth are you suggesting a thing is true that you've not looked into?

> There’s so many incarnations of Linux that surely GNU is relevant in only a small number of cases?

essentially all Linux systems aside from Alpine and Android use glibc and a GNU userland, and GCC is still the dominant compiler.

I guess this is just very low-effort trolling?


> essentially all Linux systems aside from Alpine and Android use glibc and a GNU userland, and GCC is still the dominant compiler.

when you're handwaving 3.6 BILLION devices away, maybe your case isn't as strong as you think :)


Because no one counts Android as a Linux distro, and they shouldn't. They couldn't be more oil and water from the rest of the Linux ecosystem. The term would instantly become meaningless. When people talk about alternative to glibc it's meant to be other software that lets you run applications targeting libc.


Again, hand-waving.

When the question is "how accurate is it to refer to Linux systems as GNU/Linux", and 3.6 billion devices run Android, and probably as many TVs, home internet devices (modems, wifi, etc), don't ship with the GNU userspace, then the answer very well might be "not accurate at all".

In fact, at this point, I would be surprised to learn that there are more Linux based computers running GNU userspace than not running GNU userspace.

In my house, off the top of my head, I can count 7(!) devices that I know for a fact use Linux and don't have the GNU userspace, three that I'm unsure of, and two that do. And, you probably also have more Linux devices in your household not running GNU userspace, than those that do.

As for the compiler? That's a valid point, but I don't think that earns you naming rights :) We don't call it Windows/Visual Studio 11 or macos/clang.


The ship is still Theseus'


Did they ever get Nvidia hardware working without GlibC? A quick DuckDuckGo search suggests that's still not supported.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: