Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Cisco is not a SSD manufacturer. They write industry-wide bug. Does that mean that more than one SSD manufacturer is affected (because they use partially the same firmware)? Further down they mention only Sandisk. Or is the industry-wide just their newspeak for saying any Sandisk of affected model, regardless whether installed in a Cisco box or somewhere else?


I suspect that "industry-wide bug" in this context is simply Cisco pointing out to their customer base that this isn't Cisco's fault and please don't blame Cisco.


I'm interested here too. I've got a Crucial SSD from 2015 that's been on about:

* 100% of 2015-2017, let's add 2 years here

* Aboutish 50% of days since 2018 to 2020

* On and off again (5%?) since then until now.

So it's about 3 years of full use? I'm eyeballing the use here. So it may be close to the numbers that were given, but I'm not sure. Guess I could check the SMART stats to get a precise number and from there decide what to do about it.

Searching a bit it seems it's a well-known bug in "enterprise SSDs"[0, 1] (which my drive certainly isn't) but there aren't any real details about what causes it, other than "a firmaware bug".

[0] https://www.servethehome.com/hpe-issues-hpd7-fix-for-ssds-th...

[1] https://www.anandtech.com/show/15673/dell-hpe-updates-for-40...


Enterprise SSDs are commonly made by one of a handful of dominant companies and then rebranded by server vendors, so that you can see a SanDisk or Samsung SSD sold as a Dell EMC or Cisco or HPE drive.


The problem seems to be widely experienced.

The Cisco report turned up in response to a post I'd made of the HN issue on the Fediverse:

https://mastodon.infra.de/@galaxis/108622795822100862


Dang also listed a few previous submissions on the topic.

None of which gained traction at the time:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32038993


If you google SSD 40000 hours you will find many box shifters affected, Dell, HP, IBM etc.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: