Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

For many people, it's mostly the bank's though, eh? ;)


I think you're joking, but just in case you're not (and for those reading): when you use a mortgage to buy a house, you own the house completely, and the bank owns it not at all. It's your property. That's why you can use it to secure the loan of the mortgage.

If you fail to satisfy your mortgage agreement with the bank, then yes, they can take the house from you in a foreclosure. But until then, it's yours, not theirs.


The point that was attempting to be made, which I agree with, was along the lines of the bank having the power to take it back means that they ultimately have control, regardless of the technical legal terms that indicate that the homeowner owns, well, the home. You REALLY own it after the mortgage is paid off and the bank has no interest in it. Same thing with vehicles. They're leinholders, which the first Google result defined as:

    A lienholder is a lender that legally owns your property (a car, for example) 
    until you pay it off in full. The lender — which can be a bank, financial 
    institution or private party — holds a lien, or legal claim, on the property 
    because they lent you the money to purchase it.
https://www.allstate.com/tr/car-insurance/learning-about-lie...

Edit: legally they DO differ, but they're the same in that they allow the lender to take back the property in the event of non-payment. Therefore, even though you might legally technically own a property with a mortgage, the bank still has the ability to take it away from you, so do you REALLY control it? https://www.quora.com/How-do-a-lien-and-a-mortgage-differ


The bank can't take your property unless you fail to meet your obligations, which means you, not the bank, are in control of the situation.

I understand the point being made. It's a commonly held opinion, and it's fine for inspiring people to get out of debt, but legally it's not correct. Your home is your property, even with a mortgage.

Also, a foreclosure is not the only way to lose your property. Stop paying your taxes and see what happens. Even unpaid unsecured debt (like credit cards) can lead to your home being taken in some situations. Or the government can take your property via eminent domain.

So there is no such thing as REALLY controlling property, in terms of excluding any way it can be taken from you. But you do have specific legal rights to your property, and those apply to mortgages too.




Consider applying for YC's Fall 2026 batch! Applications are open till July 27.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: